Skip to main content

B2B SaaS Route-to-Market Validation Case Study

How fifteen well-designed calls found the highest-intent oil and gas buyer, in a segment the company would never have prioritized on a whiteboard.

How a SaaS Company Found Its Highest-Intent Oil & Gas Buyer in 15 Calls

Decision Intelligence for Energy · a SaaS company seeking an oil & gas route to market · B2B SaaS · 2024

/03: The Client

A B2B SaaS company with a product that works in almost any industry, which is exactly the problem. Without a defined route to market in oil and gas, “everyone” is not a go-to-market strategy. The company needed to know which segment, which buyer, and how urgent the need actually was.

/04: The Challenge

Entering oil and gas with a horizontal product means guessing: guessing the segment, the buyer, the willingness to pay, and the timing. Guessing wrong burns months. The company wanted a fast, evidence-based read on where the real demand was before committing a go-to-market motion to it.

/05: The Solution

ModalPoint ran the validation in two rounds, fifteen calls in all.

Round one was ten phone surveys, two in each of the five oil and gas segments: upstream, midstream, downstream, service, and other. They ran over three weeks in March 2024, and every call used the same ten questions, so the answers could be laid side by side.

Round two was five in-depth interviews in the one segment that was ready to buy, each with someone who had not taken part in round one. Hearing the same people twice proves nothing. A new group either repeats the finding or breaks it.

Two rounds, fifteen calls in all

  1. Round one

    10 phone surveys

    two in each of the five oil and gas segments

  2. Round two

    5 in-depth interviews

    in the one segment that was ready to buy

Each survey crossed two readings:

  • Buying urgency: buy now, buy later, buy someday, or would not buy.
  • Seniority: from frontline managers through senior management.

The ten questions covered the current method, the biggest risks, the title responsible, the value, the yearly dollar benefit, the buying timeframe, and the segment. What came back was a validated value proposition and a prioritized target list.

/06: What We Found

Ask buyers whether a product would be valuable and most will say yes. These did, ten times out of ten, so the answer that mattered was the next one.

Every buyer said yes. Only two would buy.

All ten buyers in round one said the product would be valuable. Then they were asked when they would buy. Eight said someday: both upstream buyers, both midstream, both downstream, and both service. The two who said now were not operators at all. The real demand sat in the “other” segment and was ready to buy now.

What the ten buyers in round one said

All ten buyers in round one said the product would be valuable. Two said they would buy now, both in the other segment. The eight in upstream, midstream, downstream and service said someday.

Show the numbers as a table
SegmentSaid it would be valuableSaid they would buy now
Upstream2 of 20 of 2
Midstream2 of 20 of 2
Downstream2 of 20 of 2
Service2 of 20 of 2
Other2 of 22 of 2

Source: round one phone surveys, March 2024.

Seniority did not explain the split. The eight who said someday all sat at the same level, managers of managers, so the difference came from the segment, not from the rank of the person on the phone.

The biggest numbers came from buyers who were not ready

Buyers put a yearly dollar value on the benefit and named their biggest risk in their own words. Six of the eight who said someday named a figure, and all six named a larger one than either buyer who said now. Had the company followed the size of the number, it would have chased the buyers least ready to spend. The figures themselves stay with the client.

Where nobody was ready, nobody owned the problem

The survey also asked who is responsible for the problem today. Among the eight who said someday, four named an IT role, two named HR, and two did not know. Both buyers who said now named someone outside IT and HR. The prime contact held a different title from the ones the company had assumed.

The two groups described the risk differently too. Five of the eight who said someday called it a safety risk and four a legal one. The two who said now described money they stood to lose.

The eight who said someday, the two who said now

Of the 8 buyers who said someday, four named an IT role as the owner of the problem, two named HR and two did not know. Five called it a safety risk and four a legal one. Six named a yearly value, every one larger than either value from the 2 buyers who said now. Both buyers who said now named someone outside IT and HR and described money they stood to lose.

Show the numbers as a table
AnswerSaid someday (8)Said now (2)
Who owns the problem today: An IT role40
Who owns the problem today: HR20
Who owns the problem today: Did not know20
Who owns the problem today: Someone outside IT and HR02
How they framed the risk: Safety50
How they framed the risk: Legal40
How they framed the risk: Money they stood to lose02
Named a yearly value6, all larger2, both smaller

Source: round one phone surveys, March 2024. Ranked without figures.

/07: Outcome

The company came out with a validated buyer, a quantified value proposition, a prioritized target list, and warm next steps toward a paid proof of concept.

Fifteen calls is a small sample, and the study never claimed to size the market. Its job was narrower: tell the company where to spend its next quarter. Ten buyers who agreed on the value and split cleanly on the timing were enough to answer that.

/08: The Pattern: Why This Matters Beyond One SaaS

Most discovery calls ask whether the product would help. In this study that question could not tell the segments apart, because every buyer said yes. Two other questions did the work. When would you buy? separated now from someday. Who owns this today? showed why someday would stay someday: in most of those companies the problem belonged to IT, to HR, or to no one.

The segment that was ready was one the company would never have prioritized on a whiteboard. If you are planning a move into oil and gas, try those two questions on your next five calls and see whether the answers change your list.

Book a 30-Min Call →


Book a call

Talk to ModalPoint

A 30-minute call to see if ModalPoint is the right firm and whether the timing makes sense. No obligation either way.